kolla-ansible/doc/deployment-philosophy.rst

Kolla's Philosophy on Deployment

Overview

Kolla has an objective to replace the inflexible, painful, resource intensive deployment process of OpenStack with a flexible, painless, inexpensive deployment process. Often to deploy OpenStack at one-hundred node scale that a small business may require means building a team of OpenStack professionals to maintain and manage the OpenStack deployment. Finding people experienced in OpenStack deployment is very difficult and expensive, resulting in a big barrier for OpenStack adoption. Kolla seeks to remedy this set of problems by simplifying the deployment process but enabling flexible deployment models.

Kolla is a highly opinionated deployment tool out of the box. This permits Kolla to be deployable with configuration of three key/value pairs. As an operator's experience with OpenStack grows and the desire to customize OpenStack services increases, Kolla offers full capability to override every OpenStack service configuration option in the deployment.

Why not Template Customization?

The Kolla upstream community does not want to place key/value pairs in the Ansible playbook configuration options that are not essential to obtaining a functional deployment. If the Kolla upstream starts down the path of templating configuration options, the Ansible configuration could conceivably grow to hundreds of configuration key/value pairs which is unmanageable. Further, as new versions of Kolla are released, there would be independent customization available for different versions creating an unsupportable and difficult to document environment. Finally, adding key/value pairs for configuration options creates a situation in which a development and release cycle is required in order to successfully add a new customization. Essentially templating in configuration options is not a scalable solution and would result in an inability of the project to execute its mission.

Kolla's Solution to Customization

Rather then deal with the customization madness of templating configuration options in Kolla's Ansible playbooks, Kolla eliminates all the inefficiencies of existing deployment tools through a tidy simple design.

During deployment of an OpenStack service, a basic set of default configuration options are merged with and overridden by custom ini configuration sections. Kolla deployment customization is that simple! This does create a situation in which the Operator references the upstream documentation if a customization is desired in the OpenStack deployment. Fortunately the configuration options documentation is extremely mature and well-formulated.

As an example, consider running Kolla in a virtual machine. In order to launch virtual machines from Nova in a virtual environment, it is necessary to use the QEMU hypervisor, rather than the KVM hypervisor. To achieve this result, simply modify the file /etc/kolla/config/nova/nova-compute.conf and add the contents:

[libvirt]
virt_type=qemu

After this change Kolla will use an emulated hypervisor with lower performance. Kolla could have templated this commonly modified configuration option. If Kolla starts down this path, the Kolla project could end with hundreds of config options all of which would have to be subjectively evaluated for inclusion or exclusion in the source tree.

Kolla's approach yields a solution which enables complete customization without any upstream maintenance burden. Operators don't have to rely on a subjective approval process for configuration options nor rely on a development/test/release cycle to obtain a desired customization. Instead operators have ultimate freedom to make desired deployment choices immediately without the approval of a third party.